Gemini Community Support Site

This Gemini community support site can be used to find solutions to product issues. You can log in using Open Id, Google Profile and even Facebook. Feel free to ask a question or browse FAQs and documentation. Product tour videos are also available along with how-to videos demonstrating key Gemini capabilities.




Requesting other users review a task

web-app

One of the features of Bugzilla that I'm really missing is flags. I just filed a feature request related to this:

http://gemini.countersoft.com/issue/ViewIssue.aspx?id=3665&PROJID=2

but I'm looking for a somewhat usable workaround for a specific use-case involving code reviews. To quote from my example in the feature request:

"An example of how I want to use flags is so that team members can request code reviews. The way this would work is, when the developer would like someone else to review their code, they would set a "code review requested" flag on the task. If they want a specific member to review the code, they could specify that person as the target of the flag, and that person would receive the request notice. Otherwise, they would leave the recipient unspecified, and the request would show up on everyone's list. Once the code is reviewed, the reviewer would set the flag to approved or not approved and optionally add a comment further explaining their actions. All of this happens without having to fuss with changing task assignees or putting people on the watch list or dealing with custom fields."

I've been trying to think of a workaround that isn't incredibly kludgey, but the best I've come up with so far involved custom fields and custom states, and it's an utter failure on the kludge test. Anyone else have any thoughts?

bobw
· 1
bobw
Replies (4)
helpful
0
not helpful

Bob,

Are the code reviewers different per Project?


Harvey Kandola
· 212
Harvey Kandola
helpful
0
not helpful

Well, the requested reviewer could be any user in the system. The request may be to another developer on the team for some ideas, to a team lead for a review of general direction, to an end-user for UI feedback, etc. Theoretically, it may make sense to limit per-project, but in practice, it's not really a concern at this point.


bobw
· 1
bobw
helpful
0
not helpful

I am wondering something very similar... I am missing the CC functionality of Bugzilla where I could set the bug to a developer but copy someone in project management so they know of the bug and can monitor it. (I am another developer in this case)


nmartin
· 1
nmartin
helpful
0
not helpful

All makes sense.

Flags/cc stuff will be done at the same time as Test Cases/Plans (3.8 release, still due May).

3.7 is out in about 4 weeks time and will introduce the Project Planner (more on this on our blogs later).


Harvey Kandola
· 212
Harvey Kandola